nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo journalinfonormal searchdiv searchzone qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2022, 05, No.239 75-88
西方民族国家建构研究述评
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金铸牢中华民族共同体意识专项一般项目“世界各主要国家解决民族问题的理论政策和经验研究”(21VMZ012)
邮箱(Email):
DOI:
摘要:

以学术史视角观之,民族国家建构发端于欧洲,成长于欧美,是民族建构和国家建构的统一体。民族建构模式主要有西方模式、殖民模式、族群模式和殖民模式等,其影响因素包括教育、语言政策、国家节日、殖民历史、外交政策、领导精英、科技、区域主义和全球化等。国家建构主要有自由主义、新韦伯主义、文化主义和阶级分析等研究范式,其内容主要包括国家认同、国家能力和国家自主性的建构。民族国家建构是民族建构和国家建构的辩证统一,要坚持国家建构和民族建构相辅相成的原则,要坚持在一定条件下国家建构优先的原则,坚持民族国家建构内容的全面性和方式适当性,坚持国内和国际互构的原则。

Abstract:

KeyWords:
参考文献

(1)王伟:《中国特色“民族”概念的意涵探析》,《中央民族大学学报》2020年第3期,第41页。

(2) Anthony D.Smith,“Nations and Their Past,”Nations and Nationalism,Vol.3,No.2,1996,pp.358-365.

(3)[英]厄内斯特·盖尔纳:《民族与民族主义》,韩红译,北京:中央编译出版社,2002年,第70-77页。

(4) Pierre L.van den Berghe,The Ethnic Phenomenon,New York:Elsevier North-Holland,1981,pp.13-58.

(5) Philip Q.Yang,From Ethnic Studies:Issues and Approaches,State University of New York Press,2000,p.43.

(6) William L.Yancey,Eugene P.Ericksen and Richard N.Juliani,“Emergent Ethnicity:A Review and Reformulation,”American Sociological Review,Vol.41,No.3 (Jun.,1976),pp.391-403。

(7) Jonathan D.Sarna,“From immigrants to ethnics:Toward a new theory of‘ethnicization’,”Ethnicity,Vol.5,1978,pp.370-378.

(1) Nathan Glazer and Daniel P.Moynihan,Ethnicity:Theory and Experience,Cambridge:Harvard University Press,1975,pp.1-28.

(2) Stephanie Marrone,Whither the Nation-State?1993.p.18.https://origins.osu.edu/sites/default/files/2021-09/Volume1Issue4Article9.pdf.

(3) James Dobbins,et al.America’s Role in Nation-Building from Germany to Iraq,Santa Monica:RAND Corporation,2003,pp.1-3.

(4) Anthony D.Smith,“State-Making and Nation Building,”in John A.Hall (ed),States in History,Oxford:Blackwell Pub,1986,pp.261-262

(5) Monoj Kumar Mishra,“Elites,Nationalism and Nation-States,”International Journal of Humanities&Social Science Studies,Vol.3,Issue I,2016,pp.95-103.

(1) Joanna Pfaff-Czarnecka,“Democratisation and Nation-building in‘Divided Societies’,”in Hippler J ed.,Nation-building:AKey Concept for Peaceful Confl ict Transformation,London:Pluto Press,2005,pp.28-41.

(2) Harris Mylonas,The Politics of Nation-building:Making Co-Nationals,Refugees,and Minorities,New York:Cambridge University Press,2012,pp.17-48.

(3) Sener Arkturk,European state formation and three models of nation-building:Explaining the variation in state policies toward ethnic diversity,2015.

(4) Ezekiel Ajani,“Christian Education and Nation Building:A Focus on Nigeria,”Journal of Research on Christian Education,Vol.22,2013,pp.211-221.

(5) Roger B Myerson,A short overview of the fundamentals of state-building,2010.

(6) Cabriella Elgenius,“The Politics of Recognition:Symbols,Nation Building and Rival Nationalisms,”Nations and Nationalism,Vol.17,No.2,2011,pp.396-418.

(1) Merima Ali,Odd-Helge Fjeldstad,Boqian Jiang,Abdulaziz B Shifa,“Colonial legacy,State-building and the salience of Ethnicity in Sub-Saharan Africa,”The Economic Journal,Vol.129,Issue 619,2019,pp.1048-1081.

(2) Sabastiano Rwengabo,“Nation building in Africa:Lessons from Tanzania for South Sudan,”Discussion paper presented at Mandela Institute for Development Studies Youth Dialogue.Dar es Salaam,Tanzania:August 3-4 2016.

(3) Siti Nor Amalina Ahmad Tajuddin,Noraini Zulkepli,“An investigation of the Use of Language,Social Identity and Multicultural Values for Nation-building in Malaysian Outdoor Advertising,”Social Sciences,Vol.8,No.1,2019,pp.18-27.

(4) John Krige and Jessica Wang,“Nation,Knowledge,and Imagined Futures:Science,Technology,and Nation-Building,Post-1945,”History and Technology,2015,Vol.31,No.3,2015,pp.171-179.

(5) Mevayerore Danniel Igbini,“The Challenges of Nation-Building and Peace-Building in Nigeria,”Journal of Danubian Studies and Research,Vol.10,No.1,2020,p.425.

(6) Joseph I.Igwubor,“Traditional Institution and Nation Building:The Role of Traditional Rulers in the Maintenance of National Security for Sustainable Development,”Unizik Journal of Arts and Humanities,Vol.21,No.4,2020,p.201.

(7) Ayca Ergun,“Citizenship,National Identity,and Nation-Building in Azerbaijan:Between the Legacy of the Past and the Spirit of Independence,”Nationalities Papers,2021,p.4.doi:10.1017/nps.2020.81

(8) Rommel C.Banlaoi,Philippine Security in the Age of Terror National,Regional,and Global Challenges in the Post-9/11 World,New York:Auerbach Publications,2009,p.210.

(9) Amy Chua,World on Fire:How Exporting Free Market Democracy Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability,New York:Anchor Books,2003,p.6.

(1)邹永贤编:《国家学说史》,福州:福建人民出版社,1999年,第1-26页、145-175页、287-509页。

(2)[德]弗里德里希·威廉·尼采:《查拉图斯特拉如是说》,孙周兴译,上海:上海人民出版社,2018年,第6页。

(3) Heinrich Von Treitschke,Politics,New York:The Macmillan Company,1916,p.3.

(4)邹永贤编:《国家学说史》,第996-1152页。

(5)[德]希特勒:《我的奋斗》,北京:商务印书馆,1935年,第180页。

(1)[法]狄骥:《宪法论》,钱克新译,北京:商务印书馆,1959年,第8页。

(2)[英]道格拉斯·柯尔:《社会学说》,李平沤译,北京:商务印书馆,1960年,第53页。

(3)[美]麦基弗:《现代国家》,伦敦:牛津大学出版社,1932年,第7页。

(4)[美]汉斯·凯尔森:《法律与国家》,雷崧生译,台北:正中书局,1976年,第241页。

(5)[法]马里旦:《人和国家》,霍宗彦译,北京:商务印书馆,1964年,第15页。

(6)[美]罗伯特·达尔:《现代政治分析》,吴勇译,上海:上海译文出版社,1987年,第17-18页。

(7)[意]安东尼奥·葛兰西:《狱中札记》,葆煦译,北京:人民出版社,1983年,第221-222页。

(8)[美]赫伯特·马尔库塞:《爱欲与文明》,黄勇、薛民译,上海:上海译文出版社,1987年,第22-23页。

(9) N icos Poulantzas,State,Power,Socialism,London:Verso,pp.128-129.

(10)[美]戴维·伊斯顿:《政治生活的系统分析》,王浦劬译,北京:华夏出版社,1989年,第24页。

(11)[美]加布里埃尔·阿尔蒙德、小G.宾厄姆·鲍威尔:《比较政治学:体系、过程和政策》,曹沛霖等译,上海:上海译文出版社,1978年,第5页。

(12)[美]西达·斯考切波:《国家与社会革命:对法国、俄国和中国的比较分析》,何俊志、王学东译,上海:上海人民出版社,2007年,第3-41页。

(1) Francis Fukuyama,“The Imperative of State-Building,”Journal of Democracy,2004,Vol,15,No.2,pp.17-31.

(2) Ashraf Ghani,Clare Lockhart and Michael Carnahan,“An Agenda for State-Building,”The Fletcher Forum of World Aff airs,Vol.30,No.1,2006,p.111.

(3)[英]安东尼·吉登斯:《民族-国家与暴力》,胡宗泽、赵力涛译,北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店,1998年,第145页。

(4)[英]安东尼·史密斯:《全球化时代的民族和民族主义》,龚维斌、良警宇译,北京:中央编译出版社,2002年,第107页。

(5)参见Chales Tilly,ed.,The Formation of National States in Western Europe,Princeton,N.J.:Princeton University Press,1975;Skocpol,Theda.States and Social Revolutions:A Comparative Analysis of France,Russia and China,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1979;Peter Evans,Dietrich Rueschemeyer,and Theda Skocpol,eds.,Bring the State Back In,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1985;Michael Mann,States,War,and Capitalism:Studies in Political Sociology,New York:Blackwell Pub,1988;Joel S.Migdal,Strong Societies and Weak States:State-Society Relations and State Capabilities in the Third World,Princeton,N.J.:Princeton University Press,1988.

(6)主要是新马克思主义的观点,参见Althusser,Louis.For Marx.Translated by Ben Brewster.New York:Vintager Books,1970;Bridges,Amy Beth.“Nicos Poulantzas and the Marxist Theory of the State,”Politics and Society,1974。

(7) Peter Evans,Embedded Autonomy,States and Industrial Transformation,Princeton:Princeton University Press,1995.

(8)[美]加布里埃尔·A.阿尔蒙德、小G.宾厄姆·鲍威尔:《比较政治学:体系、过程和政策》,曹沛霖译,上海:上海译文出版社,1987年。

(9) Skocpol,Theda.States and Social Revolutions:A Comparative Analysis of France,Russia and China.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1979.

(1) Joel S.Migdal,Strong Societies and Weak States:State-Society Relations and State Capabilities in the Third World,Princeton,N.J.:Princeton University Press,1988.

(2)专制性权力指国家精英超越公民社会独断专行的权力,基础性权力指国家渗透到公民社会中,在其疆域内执行决定的能力,参见Michael Mann,States,War,and Capitalism:Studies in Political Sociology,New York:Blackwell Pub,1988。

(3)[美]弗朗西斯·福山:《国家构建:21世纪的国家治理与世界秩序》,黄胜强译,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008年。

(4) Peter Evans,Embedded Autonomy,States and Industrial Transformation,Princeton:Princeton University Press,1995.

(5) Linda Weiss,The Myth of Powerless State:Governing Economy in a Global Era,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1998,p.8.

(6)资料来源:Matthias Vom Hau,“State Theory:Four Analytical Traditions,”in Stephan Leibfried,Evelyne Huber,Matthew Lange,Jonah Levy,Frank Nullmeier,John D.Stephens,The Oxford Handbook of Transformations of the State,Oxford University Press,2015,p.133.

(7) Michael Hechter,“Introduction:Legitimacy in the Modern World,”American Behavioral Scientist,Vol.53,No.3,2009,pp.279-288.

(1) Tom R.Tyler,Why People Obey the Law,Princeton:Princeton University Press,2006,pp.3-7.

(2) Andreas Wimmer,Nationalist Exclusion and Ethnic Confl ict:Shadows of Modernity,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2002,pp.1-18.

(1) Cliff ord Geertz,Negara:The Theater State in Nineteenth Century Bali,Princeton:Princeton University Press,1980,p.13.

(2) James Scott,Seeing Like a State:How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed,New Haven:Yale University Press,1998,pp.1-8.

(1)郭忠华、谢涵冰:《民族国家建构的方式与轨迹--基于联合国会员国的分析》,《探索与争鸣》2018年第11期,第73页。

(2)扈红英:《修辞学视野下“民族国家”理论与“多民族国家”理论辨析》,《西北师大学报》2015年第5期,第78-80页。

(3)[美]弗朗西斯·福山:《国家构建:21世纪的国家治理与世界秩序》,黄胜强译,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008年。

(4) Obli Lwuagwu,Nation Building in Africa:Issues,Challenges And Emerging Trends,University of Lagos Press and Bookshop LTD,2021,p.3.

(5) Rene Grotenhuis,Nation-Building as Necessary Eff ort in Fragile States,Amsterdam:Amsterdam University Press,2016,p.29.

(6) Marina Ottaway,Anatol Lieven,“Rebuilding Afghanistan:Fantasy versus Reality,”Policy Brief,2002,p.1-8.

(7) Paul D.Miller,“The Case for Nation-building:Why and How to Fix Failed States,”Prism,Vol.3,No.1,2011,p.70.

(1) Stephen J.Rosow,The Nation-State and Global Order:A Historical Introduction to Contemporary Politics,Boulder:Lynne Rienner,2004,p.3.

(2)参见王建娥:《国家建构和民族建构:内涵、特征及联系》,《西北师大学报》2010年第2期。

(3)[英]安德鲁·海伍德编:《政治的常识》,李智译,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2014年,第74页。

(4) Danni Rodrik,“Roepke Lecture in Economic Geography:Who Needs the Nation-State?”Economic Geography,Vol.89.No.1,2012,pp.1-19.

(5) Jonathan Gienapp,“In Search of Nationhood at the Founding,”Fordham Law Review,Vol.89,Issue 5,2021,pp.1783-1813.

(6) Mariam Jorgensen,Stephanie Gutierrez,Native Nation Building:It Helps Rural America Thrive,2021,pp.1-9,https://nnigovernance.arizona.edu/sites/default/fi les/resources/TR-FP-2-Native-Nation-Building-FINAL1.pdf.

(7)王伟:《美国种族主义现象的结构性剖析》,《世界民族》2021年第6期,第1-15页。

(8) Galata Monenus Hundara,“EPRDF’s State-building Approach:Responsive or Unresponsive?”IFF Working Paper Online No.22,2017,p.4.

(1) Andebrhan Welde Giorgis,“Nation Building,State Construction and Development in Africa:The Case of Eritrea,”2010,p.16.https://library.fes.de/pdf-fi les/iez/08268.pdf

(2) Anand Sing Bhat,“Theories of Nation Building:An Analysis for Academicians and Nation Builders to Employ Nepali Army,”Unity Journal,Vol.2,2021,pp.1-17.

(3) Daniel Risiagbon Ogbeide,“Nation-Building in Nigeria:The Dilemma of A Union or Unity,”International Journal of Innovative Development and Policy Studies,Vol.9,No.3,2021,p.40.

(4) Eduardo Pastrana Buelvas,Rafael Castro Alegria,“The Long Road to State-Building in Latin America and Its Impact on Regionalization Process,”Pap.Polit.Bogota,Vol.20,No.2,2015,p.1.

(5) Matthew L.Norman,“The Challenges of State Building in Resource Rich Nations,”Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights,Vol.10,Issue 3,2012,pp.188-190.

(6) Stephen D.Krasner and Thomas Risse,“External Actors,State-Building,and Service Provision in Areas of Limited Statehood:Introduction,Governance:An International Journal of Policy,”Administration,and Institution,Vol.27,No.4,2014,p.545.

(7) Adam Read-Brown,Engaged Societies,Responsive States:The Social Contract in Situations of Conflict and Fragility,Norwegian Peacebuilding Resource Center,2016,p.7.

(8) Melissa M.Lee,“International Statebuilding and the Domestic Politics of State Development,”Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.25,No.1,2022,p.1.

(9) Francesc Serra Massansalvador,“The Process of Nation Building in Central Asia and its Relationship to Russia’s Regional Infl uence,”Jean Monnet/Robert Schuman Paper Series,Vol.10,No.5,2010,pp.1-13.

(10) Nicolas Lemay-Hebert,“State-Building From the Outside-In:UNMIK and Its Paradox,”Journal of Public and International Aff airs,Vol.20,Issue 1,2009,p.66.

(1) Pol Bargues&Pol Morillas,“From Democratization to Fostering Resilience:EU Intervention and the Challenges of Building Institutions,Social Trust,and Legitimacy in Bosnia and Herzegovina,”Democratization,Vol.28,Issue 7,2021,p.1.

(2) Keiichi Tsunekaawa,State-Building,Economic Development,and Democracy:The Japanese Experience,World Development Report,2010,p.1.

(3) Francisco Antonio-Alfonso,“Our Fragile Bodies:Economic Change,the Nation-State and the Coronavirus Pandemic,”E-International Relations,May 11,2021,pp.1-6.

(4) Sue Farran,“The Signifi cance of Sea-level Rise for the Continuation of States and the Identity of their People,”Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal,Vol.24,No.1,2021,pp.1-32.

(5) Michael Mcguire,“Nation States,Cyberconflict and the Web of Profit,”https://threatresearch.ext.hp.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/hp-bps-web-of-profi t-report_APR_2021.pdf.

(6) Dani Rodrik,“Roepke Lecture in Economic Geography:Whoe Needs the Nation-State,”Economic Geography,Vol.89,No.1,2012,pp.1-19.

基本信息:

中图分类号:D032

引用信息:

[1]王伟.西方民族国家建构研究述评[J].中央社会主义学院学报,2022,No.239(05):75-88.

基金信息:

国家社会科学基金铸牢中华民族共同体意识专项一般项目“世界各主要国家解决民族问题的理论政策和经验研究”(21VMZ012)

引用

GB/T 7714-2015 格式引文
MLA格式引文
APA格式引文
检 索 高级检索